What is the present status of the einsteincartan theory of. Myron evans ece einstein cartan evans theory physics. The viable einstein cartan sciamakibble theory of gravity was adopted by evans to describe the gravitational sector of his theory. Generally covariant unified field theory by myron w. Einsteincartanevans theory or ece theory was an attempted unified theory of physics proposed by the welsh chemist and physicist myron wyn evans may 26, 1950 may 2, 2019, which claimed to unify general relativity, quantum mechanics and electromagnetism. Spin connection resonance in magnetic motors sciencedirect.
However, since we still have a theory made of the metric and its derivatives with no other variables thrown in as. The alpha institute for advanced studies aias was founded in 1998 and is among the leading theoretical physics institutes worldwide. What is are the primary criticisms against einsteincartanevans ece field theory on wikipedia the references provided were. Einsteincartan theory is a variation of general relativity in which the affine connection is no longer presumed to be torsionfree. Myron evans, the only scientist on the hm civil list and the author of the einsten cartan evans theory was born in 1950 and was educated at pontardawe grammar school and university of wales aberystwyth, and is the author of some seven hundred papers and monographs in chemistry and physics. The extension is the introduction of cartan torsion using the standard differential geometry. Adding spacetime torsion to einsteins relativity has created the correct unified field theory. This theory is known as einstein cartan evans ece unified field theory and produces a selfconsistent framework for the investigation of field interaction in various approximations. Browse the amazon editors picks for the best books of 2019, featuring our.
What is are the primary criticisms against einstein. He is perhaps best known for the einstein cartan evans ece and ece2 unified field theory, which has been studied open source tens of millions of times. To understand this, it is enough to see that the e and b field together form an antisymmetric tensor in relativity this is the f tensor discussed in volume 2 of the feynman lectures, if you need a good source. An assessment of evans unified field theory i internet archive. Maybe someone could communicate with this forum, although ece theory is no. Cartan proposed einsteincartan theory ec to einstein in the 1920s because affine torsion is basic differential geometry. Several of evans central claims were later shown to be mathematically incorrect and, in 2008, the new editor of foundations of physics, nobel laureate. Evans one of the authors of the criticism of the einstein field equation, also available from cisp, the only scientist on the hm civil list and the author of the einsteincartan evans theory was educated at pontardawe grammar school and university of wales aberystwyth, and is the author of some. Feb 19, 2017 einstein cartan theory is a variation of general relativity in which the affine connection is no longer presumed to be torsionfree. Douglas lindstrom, phd an armchair look at ece electromagnetic theory with an explanation of lenr and other pathological science dr.
The viable einsteincartansciamakibble theory of gravity was adopted by evans to describe the gravitational sector of his theory. This book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field. The einstein cartan evans ece unified field theory is indeed an extension of the well known gravitational theory of einstein and hilbert eh field theory. You also can have a deeper understanding of how everything works. I just tought since i ran accross this question without an. Myron wyn evans was a welsh chemist and physicist who helped develop the einsteincartanevans theory or ece theory, which claimed to unify general relativity, quantum mechanics and electromagnetism. Explanation for cold fusion that was blocked by a major university is finally explained. He is perhaps best known for the einstein cartan evans ece and ece2 unified field theory, which has been studied open source tens of. Why this theory attracts me is the addition of torsion in spacetime geometry. Oct 30, 2006 this book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in 2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ecefield theory. It has been shown that unlike the consequences of exterior derivative in einstein spacetime, the repetition of d on a form of any degree is not zero. Evans, which claims to unify general relativity, quantum mechanics and electromagnetism.
In 2003 one of the four authors of this book began to construct a unified field theory of general relativity called einstein cartan evans or ece theory. Einstein cartan evans theory scitopics tu darmstadt. Einstein, cartan and evans start of a new age in physics. New books in print and planned from cambridge international science. Ece unified theory of physics by douglas lindstrom, phd. It completes the general relativity of einstein by incorporating spacetime torsion into the equations of dynamics and electrodynamics. Including also the results of an accompanying paper by obukhov and the author, we show that evans ansatz for electromagnetism is untenable beyond repair both from a geometrical as well as from a physical point. The hypothesis was largely published in the journal foundations of physics letters between 2003 and 2005. A mechanism is proposed for rotation of magnetic assemblies by a torque consisting of the magnetic dipole moment of the assembly and a magnetic field generated from spacetime in einsteincartanevans ece field theory. May 30, 2017 this is the first note of the three hundred and seventy ninth paper of ece and ece2 theories einstein cartan evans unified field theory. He to whom this emotion is a stranger, who can no longer pause to wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead. It is shown that when the magnetic assembly is stationary, the spacetime is described by a helmholtz wave equation in the tetrad as. Generally covariant unified field theory the geometrization.
In so doing, in 2003, myron evans completed einsteins quest by formulating the worlds first grand unified field theory. Einstein cartan evans theory or ece theory was an attempted unified theory of physics proposed by the welsh chemist and physicist myron wyn evans, which claimed to unify general relativity, quantum mechanics and electromagnetism. Einstein cartan theory differs from general relativity in two ways. This is a well established unified field theory which by some measures is the leading unified field theory at present. Im asking this because im not familiar at all with the mathematics that is used to prove this theory tensors etc. Einstein cartan evans theory was an attempted unified theory of physics proposed by myron w. Aug 30, 2007 enthusiasts may wish to delve deeper by inspecting the primary research papers which led to the new theory, einstein cartan evans theory or ece theory as it is also known. This book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in 2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ece field theory. The latter completes the well known work of einstein and cartan, who from 1925 to 1955 sought to unify field theory in physics with the principles of general. Einstein cartan evans unified field theory youtube. Introduction einsteins general theory of relativity is the most successful theory of gravitation.
This note derives field potential relations 17 and 18 for the electric field strength e and the acceleration due to gravity g. Advances in chemical physics, modern nonlinear optics by. According to hehl 17,18 the einsteincartan theory is the simplest and the most natural modification of the original einstein theory of gravitation. Oct 04, 2005 this book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in 2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ece field theory.
Evans and the socalled einsteincartanevans unified field theory article pdf available january 2007 with 73 reads how we measure reads. The latter completes the well known work of einstein and cartan, who from 1925 to 1955 sought to unify field theory in physics with the principles of. The easy crticism is that the theory is not lorentz invariant, which is in the paper you linked. Enthusiasts may wish to delve deeper by inspecting the primary research papers which led to the new theory, einsteincartanevans theory or ece theory as it is also known. The above introduction was written by independent researcher, michael jackson, bsee. These papers and books have been prepared since march 2003. Adding spacetime torsion to einstein s relativity has created the correct unified field theory.
It describes einstein cartan evans ece field theory from the point of view of the. Cartans equations of structure are also derived through the new derivative operator. Electrodynamics, gravitation, einsteincartan theory. In hehls opinion einsteincartan theory is an even more beautiful theory than einsteins general relativity because of its relation to the poincare group. Leverhulme fellow, humboldt fellow, british imperial chemical industries fellow, 1974, national research council canada fellow, 1974, junior research fellow wolfson college, oxford, 1975, british ramsay memorial fellow, 1976, international business machines corporation fellow. It is an organization intended to develop the outstandingly successful einstein cartan evans ece unified field theory, now the leading field theory by several measures. This geometry can be characterized by an orthonormal coframe. He developed the general theory of relativity, one of the two pillars of modern physics alongside quantum mechanics 274 einsteins work is also known for its influence on the philosophy of science. What is the present status of the einsteincartan theory. Please note that the content of this book primarily consists of articles available from wikipedia or other free sources online. This time, the geometry was correct, and physics was based on torsion.
Einsteincartan theory, and its derivation from an action i think this is usually presented in the tetrad formalism, but obviously is a more specific thing and possibly harder to find. The latter completes the well known work of einstein and cartan,who from 1925 to 1955 sought to unify field. In addition many educational articles on ece and several books. The extension is the introduction of cartan torsion using the standard differential geometry of cartan. These papers can be found on the associated website, which is that of the alpha institute for advanced studies. I would like you to tell your opinion of one of the maybe so much hated unified theories, ece einstein cartan evans by myron evans.
The ece theory has developed into about 168 source papers to date and several books and articles by ece scholars. Advances in chemical physics, dynamical processes in. It unifies general relativity and quantum mechanics using geometry, and rejects the copenhagen. Finally, einsteins unrealized dream, of a unified field theory, has been given to the world, by dr myron evans. This modification was put forward in 1922 by elie cartan, before the discovery of spin. Myron evans marquis whos who over thirty editions online is a civil list pensioner and author of about two thousand publications and broadcasts.
Counter gravitation and the faraday cage gyroscope. The latter completes the well known work of einstein and cartan, who from 1925 to 1955 sought to unify field theory in physics with the principles of general relativity. Generally covariant unified field thoery the geometrization. Felker, reno, nevada, usa version 2a, updated 20200504 summary although physicists have struggled in vain for over a halfcentury to encompass all natural forces within a unified theory, chemical physicist myron w. The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. This book describes the geometry of curving and twisting surfaces that is used to relate the geometry of spacetime to the energy density and hence to all of physics and introduces the reader to the way cartan mathematics has been developed for use in grand unified field theory. Aristotle was an encyclopedic polymath, an all time intellect. In this paper, the ece theory is illustrated with the interaction of three fields simultaneously. It is an organization intended to develop the outstandingly successful einstein cartan evans ece unified field theory, now the leading field theory by.
Myron evans, the only scientist on the hm civil list and the author of the einstencartan evans theory was born in 1950 and was educated at pontardawe grammar school and university of wales aberystwyth, and is the author of some seven hundred papers and monographs in chemistry and physics. Website for the generally covariant unified field theory, einsteincartanevans field. What is are the primary criticisms against einsteincartanevans. Jun 14, 2006 the einstein cartan theory ect of gravity is a modification of general relativity theory grt, allowing spacetime to have torsion, in addition to curvature, and relating torsion to the density of intrinsic angular momentum. Generally covariant unified field theory this book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in 2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ece field theory. This book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in 2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ecefield theory. The einstein cartan theory ect of gravity is a modification of general relativity theory grt, allowing spacetime to have torsion, in addition to curvature, and relating torsion to the density of intrinsic angular momentum. The einsteincartan evans theory alpha institute for advanced. Cartan was influenced by the work of the cosserat brothers 1909, who. Myron wyn evans born march 26, 1950, welsh physicist.
Yet not only can you know more than him about the world. In an accompanying paper by obukhov and the auth or 42, we. In 2016, the two devious hokum peddlers crothers and evans published their second book. This is the first note of the three hundred and seventy ninth paper of ece and ece2 theories einstein cartan evans unified field theory. Im searching for an undergraduatelevel explanation of the criticisms details. Cartan proposed einstein cartan theory ec to einstein in the 1920s because affine torsion is basic differential geometry. This book is the first to describe a very successful objective unified field theory which emerged in2003 and which is already mainstream physics einstein cartan evans ecefield theory. Evans one of the authors of the criticism of the einstein field equation, also available from cisp, the only scientist on the hm civil list and the author of the einstein cartan evans theory was educated at pontardawe grammar school and university of wales aberystwyth, and is the author of some. This note derives field potential relations 17 and 18 for the electric field strength e and the acceleration due to gravity.